• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

DuBose Law Firm, PLLC

Main navigation

  • Our Attorneys
    • Ben K. DuBose
    • Greg W. Lisemby
    • Brett M. Powers
  • What We Do
    • Mesothelioma
    • Serious Personal Injury
    • Employment / Labor Law
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Asbestos / Is the EPA Making Asbestos Great Again?

Is the EPA Making Asbestos Great Again?

August 8, 2018 By Ben DuBose

Is the EPA allowing asbestos again? Maybe. But there’s still time to act. The proposed EPA rule that is at the center of this firestorm is available for public comment until August 10.

Before we get to the current controversy, let’s review how we got here.

There’s Never Been an Asbestos Ban?

The undisputed recognition of asbestos as a killer lead OSHA to regulate asbestos in 1972. Millions of American lives were at stake. OSHA regulation made a real impact and saved lives by limiting asbestos exposure in the work place. In turn, many asbestos containing products could no longer be used in a way that complied with OSHA regulations. So, a steep decline in the manufacture of asbestos products ensued.

In 1989, the EPA followed up with what was to be the final blow – a complete ban on asbestos under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA). Weaknesses in TSCA, however, led to an appellate court overturning the ban. So, while Europe banned asbestos in the mid 1990s, there’s never been an outright ban on the use of asbestos in the United States. We’ve had restrictions on the deadly fiber, but no complete ban.

A New Hope

Finally, in 2016, a bipartisan effort in Congress led to a reformed TSCA giving the EPA new tools to review thousands of chemicals. Asbestos, the EPA announced in the closing days of the Obama administration, was one of the first ten chemicals to be reviewed under the new TSCA. Just two years ago, the scientific community widely believed an asbestos ban in the United States was finally in sight.

EPA Under Trump Administration

TSCA, however, requires a three year review period. Thus, the majority of the TSCA asbestos review is now happening under President Trump’s EPA. And that’s where things have taken an unexpected turn. The EPA’s approach involves a three-fold problem.

First, on June 1st, the EPA announced a “Significant New Use Rule” (SNUR) – a proposed framework that will create opportunities for “new uses” of asbestos. The EPA insists it took unprecedented action by requiring EPA approval before manufacturers can import or use asbestos in the manufacture of products. But when there is no safe level of exposure to asbestos, why create a system in which the EPA can now approve new uses of this deadly fiber? Banning asbestos would be unprecedented action – not creating a system to actually approve of new asbestos use.

Second, in May 2018, the EPA published a “Problem Formulation of the Risk Evaluation for Asbestos.” The document lays out the EPA’s planned approach for evaluating new uses of asbestos and what to consider as part of the three year TSCA asbestos review. The problem with the Problem Formulation: the EPA won’t consider pre-existing information on the health consequences of legacy uses of asbestos, such as building materials that remain in place across America. Instead, the agency will focus on “new uses for manufacture, processing or distribution is intended, known to be occurring, or reasonably foreseen.”

This will severely limit the types of exposures the EPA will include in formulating the risk of new asbestos uses. As a result – the EPA most likely will find lower levels of risk and will likely impose fewer restrictions.

Finally, the EPA recently proposed a “scientific transparency” rule which sounds great, but would prohibit the agency from considering most large scale, peer-reviewed medical research concerning the health consequences of the substances we breathe, eat and drink.

Combine all of these issues and it’s clear the EPA under the Trump administration has no plans to ban asbestos. In fact, if the SNUR rule takes effect, the EPA will have a framework to approve new asbestos uses. Existing OSHA regulations and the specter of asbestos legal liabilities will probably prevent very many new uses of asbestos from becoming a reality, but there shouldn’t be any.

The EPA’s mission is to protect human health and the environment. The proposed asbestos SNUR does neither. A U.S. ban on asbestos would.

An even broader question: if the EPA is taking such tepid measures with an undisputed human carcinogen like asbestos, what will the agency do with the thousands of lesser known chemicals still to be reviewed?

Filed Under: Asbestos, News Tagged With: Asbestos, attorney, EPA, EPA asbestos ban

Ben DuBose

About Ben DuBose

Ben DuBose has over twenty years of asbestos and serious personal injury litigation experience, successfully fighting for hundreds of mesothelioma victims in courts throughout the United States

Primary Sidebar

Mesothelioma, Lung Cancer & Serious Personal Injury Attorneys of DuBose Law Firm has decades of experience fighting for mesothelioma & personal injury victims.

Call 877-857-2914 today for free case evaluation.

Recent Posts

  • #TRUCKING DANGER: SAY NO TO HB19 & SB17!
  • Thoughts on a Year in Pandemic
  • Global Asbestos Awareness Week
  • Protecting the Right to Organize Act – PRO Act
  • Federal Task Force OKs Free Lung Cancer Early Testing

Archives

Blog Categories

  • Asbestos
    • Abatement
    • Articles
    • asbestos in talc
    • Cancer
    • Conference
    • Legal News
    • News
    • On the Job Exposure
    • Power plants
    • US Congress
  • Asbestos legal issues
  • Asbestos safety regulations
  • DuBose Law Firm News
    • Dallas asbestos attorney
    • Dallas employment lawyer
    • Dallas mesothelioma lawyer
    • Dallas personal injury lawyer
    • Louisiana asbestos attorney
    • Personal Injury
      • 18-wheeler
      • Dallas electric scooters
      • electric scooters
      • self-driving car
    • Press Releases
    • Texas asbestos lawyer
  • International asbestos developments
    • Earth Day environment
  • Laws
    • Employment Law
    • FLSA
  • Louisiana attorney
  • Lung cancer medical treatment/research
    • COVID-19
  • Medicare and Medicaid
  • Mesothelioma medical treatment/research
    • Mesothelioma
    • Mesothelioma treatment
  • mesothelioma research
    • nanotechnology
  • Miscellaneous
    • Congressional bills
    • COVID-19
      • Health
      • Pandemic
    • Holidays
      • Cinco de Mayo
      • Flag Day
      • Global Asbestos Awareness Week
      • July 4th
      • Labor Day
      • Martin Luther King
      • MLK Day
      • National Cancer Prevention Month
      • Thanksgiving
      • Veterans Day
      • World Cancer Day
    • Oil & Fracturing
    • oilfield injury
    • Veterans
  • Overtime Pay
    • FLSA wage laws
  • Personal Injury
    • Cosmetics
    • Distracted Driving
    • e-cigarettes
    • Elder abuse
    • Hand Sanitizers
    • Insurance
    • Personal injury law
    • Popcorn Lung
    • Safety
  • U.S. Navy exposure
  • Uncategorized

Secondary Sidebar

Mesothelioma and Lung Cancer

  • Mesothelioma
  • Mesothelioma Frequently Asked Questions
  • Mesothelioma Related Blog Posts
  • How to Pick an Asbestos Lawyer
  • Asbestos Information
  • Asbestos Exposure U.S. Navy List of Ships
  • Lung Cancer Claims
  • Lung Cancer is Not Just a Smoking Disease

Serious Personal Injury

  • How to Pick a Serious Personal Injury Attorney
  • Medical Litigation
  • Motor Vehicle Accidents
  • Oil Field & Gas Field Injuries
  • Personal Injury Frequently Asked Questions
  • Product Liability
  • Workplace Injuries

Employment and Labor Law Attorneys

  • Employment and Labor Law
  • Medical Leave and FMLA
  • Discrimination
  • Harassment
  • Wrongful Termination
  • Overtime Pay – Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
  • Are you a Healthcare Worker not being paid overtime wages?
  • Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act – WARN Act
  • Business Interruption Claims During COVID19 Pandemic
  • Unpaid Overtime for Dispatchers
  • Arbitration Clauses, How they impact your life
  • Asbestos Exposure on September 11, 2001
  • Mesothelioma Main Causes
  • Is Mesothelioma Cancer?

Footer

Dallas, Texas – Main Office

DuBose Law Firm, PLLC
The Adelfa B. Callejo Building
4310 N. Central Expressway
Dallas, Texas 75206
Office 214.389.8199 • Fax
214.389.8399
877-857-2914

New Orleans, LA Office

DuBose Law Firm, PLLC
829 Baronne Street
New Orleans, Louisiana 70113
Office 504.581.9322 • Fax
504.324.0155

HELPFUL FREQUENTLY USED PAGES

  • Dallas Mesothelioma Lawyer
  • New Orleans Mesothelioma Lawyer
  • Mesothelioma
  • Asbestos Information
  • How to Pick an Asbestos Lawyer
  • Mesothelioma Frequently Asked Questions
  • Serious Personal Injury
  • Personal Injury Frequently Asked Questions

Copyright DuBose Law Firm © 2021 · ; Log in